dare i say... the best season so far... idk if this is recency bias speaking but i surely believe so. carmy changed so much this season. i'm proud of him for breaking his cycles. but also bro, don't run away from the restaurant... i understand why he would want to do that, but i think he's doing it for the wrong reason because he THINKS he might be doing something good but he's running away AGAIN.
i've never been a claire hater before but i feel like after s3 she lost her narrative purpose for existing in this story. WHY is she still here?? ok i understand if carmy ran to her house to apologise to her and i liked that he finally owned up to the shitty shi he unintentionally said to her. i could totally get behind that part. but she just kept coming BACK again AND AGAIN. LIKE WHY TF WAS SHE AT TIFF'S WEDDING??? at that point i really felt like the writers were shoe-horning the claire narrative into the plot. carmy does NOT need her anymore. sydney tho? holy shit. SYDNEY. ayo NEEDS to get her emmy for this season coz she went CRAZY with the acting. sydcarmy this season? twas going so fuxxin hard. chris storer mad asf if he ain't trying to intentionally put carmy and syd together coz HOW do you write such a nuanced subtexual romance without meaning to? carmy literally confessed in the finale like bro said everything like a love confession. he was more genuine with her and knew exactly what he felt unlike with claire. like HE LITERALLY ADMITTED EVERYTHING STARTED GOING RIGHT IN HIS LIFE THE DAY SHE WALKED INTO HIS RESTAURANT AND THE WAY SYD SCREAMED "YOU'RE MY PARTNER!!" AND AND AND "I KNOW I DON'T NEED YOU TO BE HERE (BUT I WANT YOU HERE)" THE SUBTEXT THE SUBTEXT READ BETWEEN THE LINES PLEASE OHMYGOD.
okay what else... i LOVED the gang from Ever and luca joining the restaurant. jessica's chemistry with richie is so crazy, i knew they had something going on. richie deserves to be happy with her. there's a lot more stuff in general that i liked—donna's apology which made me bawl, the CRAZY season finale which was just ONE WHOLE SCENE THROUGHOUT, the wedding episode, sydney's episode w the cold opening that parelled carmy's in s1 etc. this was just peak bro. i'll stop the review here.